Monday, May 17, 2010

Omegle

You're now chatting with a random stranger. Say hi!
Stranger: hi
You: hey
You: are you a christian?
Stranger: yeah
Stranger: you?
You: nope
You: why are you a Christian?
Stranger: because I believe that God exists. I believe that Jesus came to earth to save us. I believe in the power of the Holy Spirit. I believe in God's love.
You: what reasons do you have to believe those things?
Stranger: I've seen how much the power of prayer can help when you really put your heart into it. It does work.
You: ?
Stranger: I also believe that we are naturally instilled with a sense of right and wrong that could only come from God
You: how come prayer only works for things that would have been fixed anyways
You: like
You: why doesn't God heal amputees?
You: ever?
Stranger: That would have been fixed anyway? what?
You: ya know?
Stranger: Limbs are not necessary, as harsh as that sounds.
You: like cancer going into remission, someone is sick with fever and they pray and it goes away, or whatever
You: necessary for what?
You: and
Stranger: Necessary for living, necessary in terms of doing good.
You: people all over the world pray
Stranger: and?
You: and they say it works too
Stranger: yes?
You: with just as much conviction as you do
You: even though they aren't Christians
Stranger: That's where FAITH comes into play.
Stranger: You have to trust that the religion you have chosen to follow is the true way to God.
Stranger: And I do trust that.
You: but how can you be sure you have the right religion?
Stranger: FAITH is very powerful. I've grown up around several different religions. It's not like I was just born into it or forced into it.
You: for example, a Hindu can say the same thing
You: he can say he has faith
You: just as much as you
You: except he doesn't believe in Jesus
You: and you don
You: and you don't believe in Krishna
You: so who's right?
Stranger: Yes, that's fine. I believe he is wrong. Simple as that.
You: and he believes you're wrong
You: so who's right?
Stranger: He believes I'm wrong likewise.
You: and who's right?
Stranger: Well obviously we both believe the other is right.
Stranger: I don't have to give up religion because a Hindu thinks he's right too.
Stranger: If you've faith that the religion you follow is right, that's the important thing.
You: the issue is that your reasons for being a Christian are no different than a Hindu's reason for being a Hindu
You: so essentially, your reasons aren't good reasons in the first place
You: because they can apply to any religion
Stranger: You're ignoring my explanation about faith.
You: and besides
Stranger: Why are you curious anyhow?
You: you shouldn't need faith
Stranger: Yes, you should need faith.
You: if someone says 2+2=3
You: and another says 2+2=5
You: and they both have faith in what they say
You: that doesn't mean they are right
You: they have to show that what they say is true
You: and someone who actually does add them up
You: is going to end up with four
You: and the same thing applies with religion
Stranger: When it's something spiritual, you don't have to prove yourself to any human.
Stranger: It's a personal connection between you and God, regardless of what others think.
You: then why does the Bible have so many examples of prophets trying to prove themselves to others?
You: like when Moses turned his staff into a serpent
Stranger: To spread the word of God.
You: so you DO have to prove yourself
Stranger: He wanted to save the others, not to prove himself.
You: in certain situations
You: and in order to save the others he had to prove himself
You: because
Stranger: If it means guiding others, but not for personal satisfaction.
You: you mean prove for himself?
You: so you are willing to believe that 2+2=5?
Stranger: no
Stranger: no
You: you won't bother to add it up and look at the facts?
You: you'll just take it up on faith?
Stranger: 2+2=5 is not something spiritual
You: there's no such thing as spiritual
You: that's the problem
Stranger: yes there is
Stranger: the sooner you realise it, the better
You: like
You: for example the gospels
You: are allegedly written by mark matthew luke and john
You: but in reality
You: those people didn't even actually exist
Stranger: yes they did
You: nah
You: most Bible scholars say that other people wrote the gospel
You: gospels*
You: and like, Moses can't be the author of the Pentateuch because it talks about his death and where he was buried
You: it's simple facts like that
Stranger: right, so how do you know then, if you're so into evidence, that Matthew Mark Luke and John were nonexistant and the Bible scholars were telling the truth? Why do you choose to believe that?
Stranger: That's the thing- they're not facts
You: I don't choose to believe
You: it is facts
Stranger: No, it's not.
You: sure it is
Stranger: ha
You: it's just as much fact as 2+2=4
You: this has been studied extensively
Stranger: no, it's not, grow up. also, it has been 'studied extensively' that matthew mark luke and john were the real evangelists- mark in particular has ancient bishops and historians having given written evidence on his behalf
You: it's called the synoptic problem
You: and it exists
You: and the gospels contradict each other
You: because they're made up
Stranger: why are you interested in this anyhow? If you believed there is no God, why would it matter if I believed?
Stranger: no, they're not made up.
Stranger: Human error exists too.
Stranger: The evangelists were not perfect.
You: if there's human error, then you admit that there's a possibility they could be wrong?
Stranger: No, I also believe in divine intervention when it comes to the Gospels. The Gospels are true for the vast majority, however, yes, insignificant errors and contradictions in place, time etc may occur- these are unimportant HUMAN issues- it is the message that remains unchanged
You: nonono
You: these are not unimportant human issues
Stranger: you never answered my question
You: for example
You: 2 Timothy 3:16
You: says all scripture is inspired by the lord
Stranger: yes?
You: err
You: All scripture is given by inspiration of God....
You: "All scripture is given by inspiration of God.... "
Stranger: I'm not a fundamentalist. I'm Catholic.
Stranger: and answer the question please.
You: but in 1 Corinthians 7:12, Paul says he is speaking for himself, and not for God
You: which question?
You: that's a contradiction
You: another important contradiction
You: is what to do to get saved
Stranger: the question about why you're interested in it. If there is no God, then it's not doing any harm to believe in Him.
You: yes it is
You: there is so much harm
Stranger: like?
You: all that time wasted going to church living a lie
You: all that money wasted
You: all that effort wasted
You: for a lie
You: and
You: all the terrible things that Christians have done and still continue to do
Stranger: well if we all die surely it doesn't matter then?
You: who said anything about when we die?
Stranger: What about all the terrible things athiests do and still continue to do?
You: I'm talking about the life we're living now!
You: it's spelled atheist
You: and what terrible things?
You: like
You: the recent controversy in the Catholic church with the child abuse and coverup
You: but that's just today
You: the Inquisition, counter-reformation, and all of those evil things done by the Church
Stranger: Crimes etc committed by athiests- the headlines don't say 'athiest abuses child' or anything because it doesn't capture public interest in this corrupt society- it doesn't mean it doesn't happen
You: nonono
You: you're missing something there
You: I'm talking about things that Christians do that can be based in Christianity
Stranger: 'but that's just today'- exactly! Today is the problem! The world has strayed so much from God's love by our own ignorance and that's why this society is a disaster.
You: nonono
You: I'm saying that as the current issue
Stranger: I don't believe those people are truly Christian. simple as.
You: but the Church has been corrupt from the beginning
Stranger: So has the world outside the church.
You: but the Church claims to be pure and righteous
You: that's the difference
Stranger: This planet is corrupt- there's no escaping it- purity lies in heaven.
You: no
You: a priest claims to be a holy man
You: but in reality
You: he is no more holy than the rest of us
Stranger: God is what's important, moreso than the Church.
You: same with the pope
You: and you missed an important part of what I'm saying
You: i'm not talking about just general sinfulness or whatever
You: I'm talking about stuff that is ordained by Christianity that is harmful for the world
Stranger: We are all human, fine. Priests/Popes are well-educated in terms of Catholicism and are there to guide us, not to be worshipped. At the end of the day, faith is a personal connection between the individual and God, regardless of the Church or anything associated with it.
You: for example when the Church put Galileo on trial
You: or like when the pope says that condoms don't reduce the risk of aids
Stranger: I've never said that I support everything the church has done.
Stranger: I do support the church's view against condoms though.
You: how can you be a catholic yet not support the church?
You: the pope claims to be infallible
You: that's obviously untrue
Stranger: Just because the problem is common, doesn't mean it's right. The teachings of God have not changed over the last 2000 years- the world has, yes, but that's our fault- the teachings do not need to be changed in order to mould around a corrupt world- the corrupt world needs to change to mould around the teachings.
You: the teachings of God have definitely changed
Stranger: I support the church largely but I also have my own beliefs.
Stranger: like?
You: you really think that the Christianity you believe in today is that same as hundreds of years ago?
Stranger: yes.
Stranger: Time is nothing.
You: you would probably be killed if you lived back then
Stranger: so?
You: for example
You: in today's society, slavery is unacceptable
You: yet slavery is permitted in the Bible
Stranger: The Bible didn't say slavery was a good thing.
You: and Jesus encouraged slave owners to whip their slaves
You: The Bible doesn't say slavery was a bad thing
You: and actually
You: you're wrong on tehat
You: that
You: because
You: there are many times where God tells Moses and the Israelites to take up slaves
You: in the Book of Numbers
You: Chapter 31
You: why would God tell them to do something if it wasn't good?
You: right after they kill all the men and all the women who aren't virgins
Stranger: I've never claimed to know everything. Faith, again, is important.
You: they take all the children and virgin women as slaves
You: because God told them to
Stranger: You don't have to understand God's reasons for everything to follow Him.
Stranger: Not all humans are right.
You: so you're saying there's a good reason to do own slaves?
Stranger: I'm saying I don't know the reason.
You: ok but you
You: but you're saying that there can be a good reason to own slaves?
Stranger: possibly? I don't know.
You: you really don't know?
Stranger: Yes
You: you don't know whether or not slavery is wrong?
Stranger: I believe it's wrong, but maybe I'm wrong, simple as that.
You: you really think there's a possibility that owning another human being and treating him/her as garbage can be justified at times?
Stranger: I just said I believe it's wrong?
You: but you sound like you're unsure
Stranger: I'm not unsure in my belief in God.
You: >but maybe I'm wrong
Stranger: Faith is enough for me. God's love is enough for me.
You: that's uncertainty right there
Stranger: where?
You: when you say maybe you're wrong
You: that shows doubt
You: and uncertainty
Stranger: Maybe I'm wrong and God will punish me for it- maybe my human judgement is wrong- I don't mean 'maybe I'm wrong about God'
You: but do you get what I'm saying?
Stranger: not really
You: don't you think it's ridiculous to be unsure about whether or not slavery is good?
Stranger: no, I don't
You: for example earlier you said you agreed with the church when they say condoms are bad
You: yet nowhere in the Bible does it talk about condoms
You: so do you have the same uncertainty when it comes to that as well?
You: and that's just one example
Stranger: No! Catholicism teaches that it's God's view that the main purpose of sexual relations is to produce children.
You: there are so many other terrible things that God does in the Bible
You: how can you believe in such a cruel tyrant?
You: I'll tell you what
You: I'm 100% certain that slavery is wrong
You: period
Stranger: That's your view. I have my view. That's all there is to it.
You: no
You: my view
You: is based on facts
You: the fact is
You: being a slave sucks
You: and it's painful
You: and harsh
You: and it's wrong to treat another human being like that
Stranger: It doesn't matter who's right and who isn't. We're both human. Your perception of fact is different from mine.
You: I value life
You: you can't have perception of facts
Stranger: I value God's love.
You: there is only one fact
You: where is God's love when he orders Moses to take slaves?
You: And Moses said unto them, Have ye saved all the women alive? ... Now therefore kill every male among the little ones, and kill every woman that hath known man by lying with him. But all the women children, that have not known a man by lying with him, keep alive for yourselves.--Num.31:15-19
Stranger: I believe that a lot of what humans have come to know as fact may be wrong in God's eyes. His power is beyond the capability and understanding of any of us.
You: if he's beyongd the capability and understanding, then how can you be so certain?
You: and besides
You: that's a cop out
Stranger: His love is extremely powerful and I've felt that.
You: so did the virgin women who were taken as sex slaves feel his love too?
You: or all the innocent male children who were killed
Stranger: I don't care for evidence or facts- I care for God's righteousness.
You: all for God's love?
You: where is God's righteousness when he advocates slavery?
Stranger: As I've said, I've never claimed to understand God's reasons. I'm only human.
You: it's completely cruel and inhumane
You: I'll tell you why you can't understand them
You: because they don't exist
You: there IS NO GOOD REASON TO OWN A SLAVE
You: ever
Stranger: YOU believe they don't exist. Your beliefs are different from mine, that's it.
You: no
Stranger: yes
You: it's not a belief
You: it's a fact
You: it's a fact that slavery is a degenerate morality
You: because it goes against everyone's basic ethics
You: nobody would chose to be a slave
You: I don't know what country you're from
You: but I'm from Texas in the United States
Stranger: 'suffer little, children who come onto me, for there's is the kingdom of heaven' People may suffer on earth but they will receive consolation in Heaven
You: and in our parts of the world we say slavery is wrong
You: even though that contradicts the Bible
You: because we realize that the morals in the Bible are repugnant
You: we don't make excuses
You: saying that God works in mysterious ways or whatever
You: you need to open your eyes and accept the truth
You: there is no God
You: he's just fiction like Santa Claus
You: except worse, because Santa Claus doesn't tell people to own slaves
Stranger: Your idea of truth is different to mine- you are not going to change my views. I've argued with athiests on several occassions- I'm staying firm in my belief in God. I'm not willing to fall prey to the threat of Hell.
You: it's spelled atheist
Stranger: sorry
You: and if you're afraid of hell
You: that means you follow a tyrant
You: it's no different than running drugs for a mobster because you're afraid he'll murder your family
You: and
You: are you just as afraid as Islamic hell?
You: because you know that if Islam is true, you're going to hell
You: so why don't you convert to Islam to be safe?
You: the reality is
You: there is no heaven
Stranger: Because, like I said before, I have FAITH that Christianity is the way to God
You: and you can say that you have faith
You: but that's meaningles
You: it just means you give up on thinking things out yourself
Stranger: YOUR PERCEPTION OF REALITY IS NOT THE SAME AS MINE. ACCEPT IT.
Stranger: I offer it over to God- His will be done. Fine.
You: you can have faith in Christianity all you want, but when the time comes, Allah is going to condemn you to hell for not believing in the Quran
You: and you know what?
Stranger: So you're islamic?
You: A Muslim would say the same thing as you
You: he would say that he has faith
Stranger: so?
You: so when you say you have faith, it means nothing
You: because they have faith too
You: if you were born in India you would be a Hindu right now telling me you have faith in Vishnu
You: faith is 100% arbitrary
You: it's just a cop out
Stranger: It means something to me- I trust that my beliefs are right. I don't need 'evidence' for that. I'm willing to stand by my views regardless of human questioning.
You: you have no legitimate reason to do so
You: so... your faith is no different than people who believe that Elvis is still alive
You: because they say they have faith too
You: or kids that believe in Santa Claus
Stranger: How many times do I need to say that I believe what I believe because I have faith. I don't need 'legitimitate reasons'. Arguing with me is not going to make me stop believing in God.
You: see?
Stranger: what?
You: you're saying "I have faith that 2+2=5. I don't need to actually add two and two together, I just trust my faith that they equal five"
Stranger: God bless you. Why do you need to be so argumentative?
You: so you agree then that your faith is arbitrary and counter-productive?
You: think of all the things that people accomplished without faith
You: when instead they used evidence
Stranger: I'm sticking to my faith. Other people may stick to their opposing faiths. That's fine. End of.
You: you're using a computer
You: you think it's based on faith
You: that someone designed a computer?
You: or modern medicine?
Stranger: Freewill.
You: it's when people rejected faith as an epistemological stance
You: that we began a huge acceleration in advancement
You: when doctors and scientists performed experiments
You: to prove their medicines work
You: can you imagine if your doctor gave you a pill and said "I haven't actually checked what effects this pill has. I have faith it will heal you."
Stranger: When are you going to realise that any 'evidence' or examples aren't going to change my mind?
You: you've already changed your mind
You: you just don't realize it yet
Stranger: Maybe you think I'm wrong, but that's fine by me.
You: you've already said that you have doubt
You: that you're uncertain
You: whether slavery is good or bad
You: but you don't want to admit it
Stranger: I have faith in God. I don't need to prove that to you or to anyone.
You: because you're afraid that it might actually turn out that you're wrong
You: you can have all the faith you want
You: but that doesn't change the facts
You: you can change opinions, but you can't change the facts
Stranger: I'm not afraid that I'll turn out wrong.
You: 2+2=4 no matter how much faith you have
Stranger: I don't care.
Stranger: That's all there is to it.
You: so you say you're not afraid
You: now you sound full of conviction
You: but earlier you expressed doubt
You: this is just a sympton
You: symptom
You: of a bigger problem
You: you're trying to reassure yourself
You: because you have doubt
You: it's ok
Stranger: I'm human. I've never claimed to be perfect. I have my beliefs and I'm sticking to them.
Stranger: I don't care whether or not you think I have doubt.
You: just letting you know
You: that there is more to life than God
You: enjoy your life
You: because it's all you have
You: when you die it's over
Stranger: In YOUR opinion.
You: there's no heaven or hell
You: no this is a fact lol
Stranger: In YOUR opinion
You: and you can have all the faith you want
You: but in the end
You: you're going to be laying in a grave
You: while you decompose
You: and that's the end of it
Stranger: My faith will lead me to God, regardless of your views.
You: have a nice night
You have disconnected.